网站版权 © 《油气储运》编辑部 陕ICP备11014090号-10
地址：河北省廊坊市金光道51号（065000）；电话：0316-2176193 / 0316-2072055； 传真:0316-2177392； 网址：yqcy.paperonce.org
技术支持：西安三才科技实业有限公司 029-89381847；029-88222991
[1]武刚,张庶鑫,罗金恒,等.基于TOPSIS的原油储罐风险分级预警[J].油气储运,2024,43(06):641-648.[doi:10.6047/j.issn.1000-8241.2024.06.005]
WU Gang,ZHANG Shuxin,LUO Jinheng,et al.Graded early warning for crude oil tanks based on TOPSIS[J].Oil & Gas Storage and Transportation,2024,43(06):641-648.[doi:10.6047/j.issn.1000-8241.2024.06.005]
点击复制
WU Gang,ZHANG Shuxin,LUO Jinheng,et al.Graded early warning for crude oil tanks based on TOPSIS[J].Oil & Gas Storage and Transportation,2024,43(06):641-648.[doi:10.6047/j.issn.1000-8241.2024.06.005]
基于TOPSIS的原油储罐风险分级预警
《油气储运》[ISSN:1000-8241/CN:13-1093/TE]
卷:
43
期数:
2024年06期
页码:
641-648
栏目:
检测与完整性
出版日期:
2024-06-25
- Title:
- Graded early warning for crude oil tanks based on TOPSIS
- 文章编号:
- 1000-8241（2024）06-0641-08
- Keywords:
- crude oil tank; technique for order preference by similarity to ideal solution; TOPSIS; risk assessment; analytic hierarchy process; graded early warning
- 分类号:
- TE972.1
- 文献标志码:
- A
- 摘要:
- 【目的】原油储罐目前普遍趋向于大型化、集中化。由于原油理化性质与储罐材料构件的复杂性，造成储罐的高风险性，需提高储罐罐区风险管理能力。应用现有主流的基于风险的检验技术（Risk Based Inspection,RBI）对储罐风险进行评价较为复杂，其对于现场数据要求较多，且设备因素评价中缺少针对储罐相关附件的影响分析。【方法】提出一种原油储罐分级预警体系，通过建立基于逼近理想解排序方法（Technique for Order Preference by Similarity to an Ideal Solution,TOPSIS）的储罐风险分级预警体系模型，实现对储罐风险的综合评估与分级预警：①建立储罐风险评估指标体系，包括人、设备、环境及管理因素4个一级指标以及若干二级、三级指标；②应用层次分析法（Analytic Hierarchy Process,AHP）对不同层次指标进行赋权，并利用TOPSIS方法对储罐进行相对贴近度计算；③根据相对贴近度结果对储罐进行风险排序与分级预警。【结果】以中国西部某原油储备库区4个原油储罐为研究对象进行风险分级预警，TOPSIS评估结果与API581-2016《基于风险的检验》、EEMUA159-2017《地上平底储罐：检查维护和修理指南》两种标准的风险评估结果基本一致，可有效预警，且实施便捷、评价指标更为全面。【结论】研究成果能够为罐区巡检、安排储罐大修周期提供合理参考。（图2，表8，参20）
- Abstract:
- [Objective] Given the rise in large-scale and centralized crude oil tanks, along with the physical and chemical properties of crude oil and the intricate nature of tank materials and components, these tanks present substantial risks. Consequently, enhancing the risk management capabilities of tank farms becomes imperative to enable enterprises overseeing routine tank management to acquire a comprehensive grasp of tank conditions. However, the prevailing risk-based inspection technology, mandated by current foreign standards, poses challenges in practical execution, primarily due to the extensive field data requirements. Moreover, there is a lack of impact analysis focusing on tank accessories in the assessment of equipment factors. [Methods] This paper presents a graded early warning system for crude oil tanks, incorporating a model based on the Technique for Order Preference by Similarity to an Ideal Solution (TOPSIS) to facilitate a comprehensive assessment and graded early warning of tank risks. (1) The established system of tank risk assessment indicators includes 4 primary indicators of human, equipment, environment, and management factors and several secondary and tertiary indicators. (2) The Analytic Hierarchy Process is integrated to assign weights to indicators at different levels, and the TOPSIS method is utilized to calculate the relative proximity of tanks. (3) Risks are ranked to enable graded early warning for tanks according to the results of relative proximity. [Results] The graded early warning of risks was carried out for 4 crude oil tanks located at a crude oil depot in western China. The assessment results closely aligned with those derived from API 581-2016 Risk-based Inspection Methodology and EEMUA 159-2017 Above Ground Flat Bottomed Storage Tanks: A Guide to Inspection, Maintenance and Repair. This alignment proved the efficacy of the proposed system in early warning, highlighting its convenience in execution and its coverage of more assessment indicators. [Conclusion] The study results serve as rational references for tank farm patrol inspections and tank overhaul scheduling. (2 Figures, 8 Tables, 20 References)
参考文献/References:
[1] 孙东亮，李子杰.典型自然灾害引发常压储罐破坏的定量风险评估[J].安全与环境学报，2022，22（3）：1178-1186. 10.13637/j.issn.1009-6094.2020.1734. SUN D L，LI Z J. Quantitative risk analysis on damage to atmospheric vessels initiated by typical natural disasters[J]. Journal of Safety and Environment，2022，22(3):1178-1186.
[2] RIAHI M，SHAMEKH H，KHOSROWZADEH B. Differentiation of leakage and corrosion signals in acoustic emission testing of aboveground storage tank floors with artificial neural networks[J]. Russian Journal of Nondestructive Testing，2008，44(6):436-441. DOI:10.1134/S1061830908060107.
[3] KANG J，LIANG W，ZHANG L B，LU Z，LIU D T，YIN W Z，et al. A new risk evaluation method for oil storage tank zones based on the theory of two types of hazards[J]. Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries，2014，29:267-276. DOI:10.1016/j.jlp.2014.03.007.
[4] 任贵红，张苗，谢飞，陶晓雪，李克荣，宋文华.基于模糊数学和灰色关联分析的化工储罐区火灾风险评估研究[J].中国安全生产科学技术，2013，9（2）：105-111. REN G H，ZHANG M，XIE F，TAO X X，LI K R，SONG W H. Study on fire risk assessment of chemical storage tank area based on fuzzy mathematics and grey relational analysis[J]. Journal of Safety Science and Technology，2013，9(2):105-111.
[5] 祁云清，姚安林，朱元杰，黄亮亮，鲜涛.基于可拓理论的油气站场完整性管理质量评价方法研究[J].中国安全生产科学技术，2014，10（10）：185-190. 10.11731/j.issn.1673-193x.2014.10.031. QI Y Q，YAO A L，ZHU Y J，HUANG L L，XIAN T. Research on quality assessment method of integrity management on oil and gas station based on extension theory[J]. Journal of Safety Science and Technology，2014，10(10):185-190.
[6] 周娇，鲍磊，于安峰，凌晓东，刘金玲，姜雪.基于韦伯分布与RBI理论修正的加氢母站设备可靠性分析[J].科学技术与工程，2023，23（27）：11900-11907. 10.3969/j.issn.1671-1815.2023.27.050. ZHOU J，BAO L，YU A F，LING X D，LIU J L，JIANG X，et al. Reliability analysis of hydrogenation master station equipment based on Weibull distribution and modified RBI theory[J]. Science Technology and Engineering，2023，23(27):11900-11907.
[7] SALZANO E，GARCIA AGREDA A，DI CARLUCCIO A，FABBROCINO G. Risk assessment and early warning systems for industrial facilities in seismic zones[J]. Reliability Engineering & System Safety，2009，94(10):1577-1584. DOI:10.1016/j.ress.2009.02.023.
[8] ZULUAGA MAYORGA S，S?NCHEZ-SILVA M，RAM?REZ OLIVAR O J，MU?OZ GIRALDO F. Development of parametric fragility curves for storage tanks:A Natech approach[J]. Reliability Engineering & System Safety，2019，189:1-10. DOI:10.1016/j.ress.2019.04.008.
[9] 周浩东，姚锡文，许开立，徐晓虎，孙恩吉.基于故障树-贝叶斯-蝴蝶结分析的复合事故风险模型研究[J].工业安全与环保，2020，46（8）：6-10，47. 10.3969/j.issn.1001-425X.2020.08.002. ZHOU H D，YAO X W，XU K L，XU X H，SUN E J. Study on composite accident model based on fault Tree-Bayesian-Bow-Tie analysis[J]. Industrial Safety and Environmental Protection，2020，46(8):6-10，47.
[10] 马鑫龙.化学园区苯储罐泄漏风险分析[J].中国特种设备安全，2023，39（9）：71-76. 10.3969/j.issn.1673-257X.2023.09.016. MA X L. Risk analysis of benzene tank leakage in chemical park[J]. China Special Equipment Safety，2023，39(9):71-76.
[11] 陈俊仰，李绪丰，孙杰，季鹏，傅如闻.在役大型常压储罐基于风险的检验技术应用[J].机电工程技术，2023，52（8）：187-191，205. 10.3969/j.issn.1009-9492.2023.08.040. CHEN J Y，LI X F，SUN J，JI P，FU R W. Application of inspection technology based risk in service large-scale normal pressure storage tank[J]. Mechanical & Electrical Engineering Technology，2023，52(8):187-191，205.
[12] 王霞，段庆全.基于改进理想点解法的油气管道事故综合预测研究[J].中国安全生产科学技术，2018，14（4）：119-125. 10.11731/j.issn.1673-193x.2018.04.019. WANG X，DUAN Q Q. Study on comprehensive prediction of oil and gas pipeline accidents based on improved TOPSIS[J]. Journal of Safety Science and Technology，2018，14(4):119-125.
[13] 王霞，段庆全.基于改进层次分析法的油气管道风险因素权重计算[J]. 油气储运，2019，38（11）：1227-1231. 10.6047/j.issn.1000-8241.2019.11.004. WANG X，DUAN Q Q. A method for calculating the weight of oil and gas pipeline risk factor based on improved analytic hierarchy process[J]. Oil & Gas Storage and Transportation，2019，38(11):1227-1231.
[14] LIU H，HONG R，LANG Z H，YAO J Y，YE D，SHAN J L，et al. Evaluation of the spontaneous combustion tendency of corrosion products in oil tanks based on TOPSIS methodologies[J]. Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries，2021，71:104475. DOI:10.1016/j.jlp.2021.104475.
[15] 黄堃.立式钢制锥底油罐底板排板方式分析与改进[J].油气储运，2023，42（2）：197-205. 10.6047/j.issn.1000-8241.2023.02.009. HUANG K. Analysis and optimization on plate arrangement for conical bottom of vertical steel oil tank[J]. Oil & Gas Storage and Transportation，2023，42(2):197-205.
[16] WANG X，DUAN Q Q. Improved AHP–TOPSIS model for the comprehensive risk evaluation of oil and gas pipelines[J]. Petroleum Science，2019，16(6):1479-1492. DOI:10.1007/s12182-019-00365-5.
[17] ARENA E，FARGIONE G，GIUDICE F，LATONA E. RBI-IOWs integrated approach to risk assessment:Methodological framework and application[J]. Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries，2022，79:104838.
[18] LIU Z H，ZHOU J F，RENIERS G. Association analysis of accident factors in petrochemical storage tank farms[J]. Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries，2023，84:105124.
[19] 林现喜.基于保护层分析法的大型LNG储罐风险分级管控[J]. 油气田地面工程，2021，40（11）：52-57. 10.3969/j.issn.1006-6896.2021.11.010. LIN X X. Risk grading management of large-scale LNG tank based on layer of protection analysis method[J]. Oil-Gas Field Surface Engineering，2021，40(11):52-57.
[20] 付明福，张明星，朱晓曼，龚晓凤，谭波.油气长输管道作业分级定量风险评价方法研究及应用[J].中国安全生产科学技术，2019，15（7）：137-141. 10.11731/j.issn.1673-193x.2019.07.022. FU M F，ZHANG M X，ZHU X M，GONG X F，TAN B. Research and application of quantitative risk assessment method for operation classification of oil and gas long-distance pipeline[J]. Journal of Safety Science and Technology，2019，15(7):137-141.
相似文献/References:
[1]陆雅红,吴江涛,周永,等.原油储罐的节能措施[J].油气储运,2010,29(5):390.[doi:10.6047/j.issn.1000-8241.2010.05.024]
Lu Yahong,Wu Jiangtao,Zhou Yong.Energy Saving Measures for Oil Tanks[J].Oil & Gas Storage and Transportation,2010,29(06):390.[doi:10.6047/j.issn.1000-8241.2010.05.024]
[2]邹永胜,庞贵良,邱姝娟.原油储罐罐底原油重质组分处理方法[J].油气储运,2011,30(08):668.[doi:10.6047/j.issn.1000-8241.2011.08.018]
Zou Yongsheng,Pang Guiliang,Qiu Shujuan.Treating method of heavy fractions in the bottom of crude oil tank[J].Oil & Gas Storage and Transportation,2011,30(06):668.[doi:10.6047/j.issn.1000-8241.2011.08.018]
[3]王永强,巴胜富,韩彩红,等.大型原油储罐全封闭清洗工程施工实践[J].油气储运,2011,30(10):795.[doi:10.6047/j.issn.1000-8241.2011.10.024]
Wang Yongqiang,Ba Shengfu,Han Caihong,et al.Practice in cleaning large-scale crude oil tank based on total enclosure way[J].Oil & Gas Storage and Transportation,2011,30(06):795.[doi:10.6047/j.issn.1000-8241.2011.10.024]
[4]张伟,徐明海.单井原油储罐加热方式的优选[J].油气储运,2010,29(7):548.[doi:10.6047/j.issn.1000-8241.2010.07.021]
Zhang Wei,Xu Minghai.Optimization of Heating Method for Single-well Crude Oil Tank[J].Oil & Gas Storage and Transportation,2010,29(06):548.[doi:10.6047/j.issn.1000-8241.2010.07.021]
[5]李刚,黄晓真,李学军.集油储罐腐蚀分析与防护措施[J].油气储运,2009,28(5):59.[doi:10.6047/j.issn.1000-8241.2009.05.018]
LI Gang,HUANG Xiaozhen.Analysis of Oil Gathering Tank’s Corrosion and Corrosion Control Measures[J].Oil & Gas Storage and Transportation,2009,28(06):59.[doi:10.6047/j.issn.1000-8241.2009.05.018]
[6]贾宗贤.油罐加热盘管泄漏回水检测工艺[J].油气储运,2003,22(7):55.[doi:10.6047/j.issn.1000-8241.2003.07.017]
JIA Zongxian.Inspection Process of Leakage of Return Water of Heating Coil in Oil Tank[J].Oil & Gas Storage and Transportation,2003,22(06):55.[doi:10.6047/j.issn.1000-8241.2003.07.017]
[7]王国涛,楚海明,慕希茂.COWS原油储罐清洗技术在黄岛油库的应用[J].油气储运,2002,21(3):57.[doi:10.6047/j.issn.1000-8241.2002.03.018]
WANG Guotao,CHU Haiming.COWS Technology Used in Crude Oil Tank[J].Oil & Gas Storage and Transportation,2002,21(06):57.[doi:10.6047/j.issn.1000-8241.2002.03.018]
[8]偶国富,金浩哲,王勇,等.大型双盘浮顶原油储罐密封泄漏损耗分析[J].油气储运,2008,27(6):58.[doi:10.6047/j.issn.1000-8241.2008.06.016]
OU Guofu,JIN Haozhe.Seal Leakage Loss Analysis for Large Double Deck Floating-roof Crude Oil Storage Tank[J].Oil & Gas Storage and Transportation,2008,27(06):58.[doi:10.6047/j.issn.1000-8241.2008.06.016]
[9]储祥萍,宋晓东.储罐自动化系统的研发及应用[J].油气储运,2007,26(5):59.[doi:10.6047/j.issn.1000-8241.2007.05.018]
CHU Xiangping,SONG Xiaodong.Development and Application of Automation System for Oil Storage Tankfarm[J].Oil & Gas Storage and Transportation,2007,26(06):59.[doi:10.6047/j.issn.1000-8241.2007.05.018]
[10]李海光.原油储罐清洗方法[J].油气储运,2006,25(4):59.[doi:10.6047/j.issn.1000-8241.2006.04.016]
LI Haiguang.Cleaning Technology for Oil Tank[J].Oil & Gas Storage and Transportation,2006,25(06):59.[doi:10.6047/j.issn.1000-8241.2006.04.016]
[11]武刚,张庶鑫,罗金恒,等.基于TOPSIS的原油储罐风险分级预警[J].油气储运,2024,43(06):1.
WU Gang,ZHANG Shuxin,LUO Jinheng,et al.Graded early warning for crude oil tanks based on TOPSIS[J].Oil & Gas Storage and Transportation,2024,43(06):1.
备注/Memo
武刚，男，1985年生，高级工程师，2011年硕士毕业于北京科技大学机械设计与理论专业，现主要从事油气管道及储存设施完整性技术方面的研究与工程技术服务工作。地址：陕西省西安市雁塔区锦业二路89号，710077。电话：029-81887736。Email：wugang010@cnpc.com.cn
基金项目：“十三·五”国家重点研发计划“原油天然气储罐及附属管道、辅助设施安全评定与风险评价预警研究”，2017YFC0805804；中国石油天然气股份有限公司科学研究与技术开发项目“油气田站场完整性管理技术研究”，2021DJ2804。
· Received: 2023-07-09 · Revised: 2023-10-03 · Online: 2024-04-07
更新日期/Last Update:
2024-06-25