版权所有@2014 《油气储运》杂志社 冀ICP备号:0000000
地址:河北省廊坊市金光道51号(065000);电话:0316-2177193 / 0316-2176753; 传真:0316-2177392; 网址:yqcy.paperonce.org
技术支持:西安三才科技实业有限公司 029-88222991
小型航煤储罐的吸瘪机理
Collapse mechanism of small aviation kerosene tank
storage tank
; eigenvalue buckling analysis; nonlinear buckling analysis; defect; finite element针对新疆某100 m3 航煤储罐的吸瘪事故,采用数值仿真技术,通过高阶壳单元有限元模型进 行了特征值屈曲分析和非线性屈曲分析,对小型航煤储罐的吸瘪机理进行了详细探讨。通过储罐运 行参数确定罐体承受负压范围,通过模态分析确定无缺陷罐体承受的极限负压,对比了不同工况下 储罐的变形和受力分布,确定了有缺陷储罐极限负压。研究表明,单纯负压并不能导致储罐吸瘪,初 始缺陷和呼吸不畅引发的负压共同导致储罐吸瘪,同时可根据临界载荷确定吸瘪时的储罐呼吸阀通 气量。研究成果可为储罐的修复及后续安全生产提供参考。(图8,表2,参20)
In order to investigate the reason for collapse of a 100 m3 aviation kerosene storage tank in Xinjiang, eigenvalue buckling analysis and nonlinear buckling analysis were conducted with the numerical simulation technology based on the finite element model (FEM) of a high-order shell unit, and the collapse mechanism of small aviation kerosene was discussed in detail. According to the operation parameters of the tank, the bearing capacity of negative pressure was determined for the tank, and through modal analysis, its ultimate bearing capacity of negative pressure was determined for the tank without any defect. The deformation and stress distribution of the tank under various working conditions were compared, and the ultimate bearing capacity of negative pressure for the defective tank was determined. The study shows that only the negative pressure itself could not have led to the collapse of tank, but the initial defect together with the negative pressure caused by unsmooth breathing could result in collapse of tank. Additionally, the ventilation rate of the breathing valve at the moment the tank collapses can be determined based on the critical load. The study results could provide reference for the repair and subsequent safe operation of the tank. (8 Figures, 2 Tables, 20 References)
[1] GODOY L A. Buckling of vertical oil storage steel tanks: Review of static buckling studies[J]. Thin-Walled Structures, 2016, 103(1): 1-21.
[2] 魏化中,张占武,丁克勤,舒安庆. 大型立式储罐风致静力屈曲 分析[J]. 化工装备技术,2012,33(6):8-12.
WEI H Z, ZHANG Z W, DING K Q, SHU A Q. Buckling analysis of large vertical type storage tank by static wind load[J]. Chemical Equipment Technology, 2012, 33(6): 8-12.
[3] YASUNAGA J, YAMAGUCHI T, UEMATSU Y. Effects of wind girders on the buckling and vibration of open-topped oil storage tanks under wind loads[J]. Journal of Wind Engineering, 2016, 41(2): 58-67.
[4] BURGOS C A, JACA R C, LASSIG J L, GODOY L A. Wind buckling of tanks with conical roof considering shielding by another tank[J]. Thin-Walled Structures, 2014, 84: 226-240.
[5] 杨宏康,高博青. 立式圆柱形储液罐屈曲问题研究综述[C]. 天 津:庆贺刘锡良教授执教六十周年暨第十一届全国现代结构工 程学术研讨会,2011:885-891.
YANG H K, GAO B Q. Review of buckling research of cylindrical liquid storage tank[C]. Tianjin: Celebration on 60 years of teaching of Pr. Liu Xiliang and 11st National Modern Structure Engineering Seminar, 2011: 885-891.
[6] DJERMANE M, ZAOUI D, LABBACI B, HAMMADI F. Dynamic buckling of steel tanks under seismic excitation: Numerical evaluation of code provisions[J]. Engineering Structures, 2014, 70(9): 181-196.
[7] GONG J G, TAO J, ZHAO J, ZENG S, JIN T. Buckling analysis of open top tanks subjected to harmonic settlement[J]. Thin- Walled Structures, 2013, 63(11): 37-43.
[8] 苏文献,韩超. 大型储罐屈曲失效及修复的有限元模拟[J]. 压力 容器,2011,28(1):51-57.
SU W X, HAN C. Finite element simulation of collapse and restoration of large-size storage tank shell[J]. Pressure Vessel Technology, 2011, 28(1): 51-57.
[9] RASTGAR M, SHOWKATI H. Buckling behavior of cylindrical steel tanks with concavity of vertical weld line imperfection[J]. Journal of Constructional Steel Research, 2018, 145: 289-299.
[10] SHOKRZADEH A R, SOHRABI M R. Buckling of ground based steel tanks subjected to wind and vacuum pressures considering uniform internal and external corrosion[J]. Thin- Walled Structures, 2016, 108: 333-350.
[11] 张浩. 10 万m3 浮顶罐在罐底沉降及风载荷作用下的屈曲行为 分析与实验研究[D]. 杭州:浙江大学,2016:46-48.
ZHANG H. Buckling behavior and experimental research of floating roof tanks subjected to settlement and wind load[D]. Hangzhou: Zhejiang University, 2016: 46-48.
[12] 孙颖,崔利富,孙建刚,赵颖华. 三向地震激励下浮顶储罐动力 屈曲[J]. 大连海事大学学报,2012,38(3):121-125.
SUN Y, CUI L F, SUN J G, ZHAO Y H. Dynamic buckling of vertical storage tanks with flowing roof under 3-D earthquake excitation[J]. Journal of Dalian Maritime University, 2012, 38(3): 121-125.
[13] 宫建国. 立式圆柱形钢制储罐在谐波沉降下的屈曲行为及缺 陷敏感度研究[D]. 杭州:浙江大学,2014:109-110.
GONG J G. Buckling behavior and imperfection sensitivity analyses of vertical cylindrical steel tanks subjected to harmonic settlement[D]. Hangzhou: Zhejiang University, 2014: 109-110.
[14] GRIFFIN M L. Protecting atmospheric storage tanks against vacuum collapse[J]. Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries, 2000, 13(2): 83-89.
[15] 徐英,杨一凡,朱萍. 球罐和大型储罐[M]. 北京:化学工业出 版社,2005:178-180.
XU Y, YANG Y F, ZHU P. Spherical and large storage tanks[M]. Beijing: Chemical Industry Press, 2005: 178-180.
[16] 林寅. 大型钢储罐结构的风荷载和风致屈曲[D]. 杭州:浙江 大学,2014:92-110.
LIN Y. Wind load and wind-induced buckling of large steel tanks[D]. Hangzhou: Zhejiang University, 2014: 92-110.
[17] 赵慧磊. 大型储罐外压稳定性分析[D]. 北京:北京化工大学, 2009:21-22.
ZHAO H L. Study of stability of large tank subjected to external pressure[D]. Beijing: Bejing University of Chemical Technology, 2009: 21-22.
[18] 高健富,高炳军,靳达,李娜,宋晞明,傅建楠. LNG 储罐罐体结 构与载荷的关联性[J]. 油气储运,2019,38(3):321-327.
GAO J F, GAO B J, JIN D, LI N, SONG X M, FU J N. Relevance between structure and load of LNG storage tank[J]. Oil & Gas Storage and Transportation, 2019, 38(3): 321-327.
[19] 罗珊,王纬波. 基于弧长法的受压球壳稳定性分析[J]. 应用力 学学报,2020,37(1):161-167.
LUO S, WANG W B. Stability analysis of spherical pressure hull based on arc length method[J]. Chinese Journal of Applied Mechanics, 2020, 37(1): 161-167.
[20] 张翀宇. 原油储罐有缺陷状态下结构稳定性的研究[J]. 装备制 造技术,2016(11):161-164.
ZHANG C Y. Study on the structural stability of crude oil tank with defective condition[J]. Equipment Manufacturing Technology, 2016(11): 161-164.
[1]吴龙平,王文娜,刘毅,等.钢制焊接储罐晃动波高的计算[J].油气储运,2015,34(8):882.[doi:10.6047/j.issn.1000-8241.2015.08.017]
WU Longping,WANG Wenna,LIU Yi,et al.Calculation of sloshing wave height of steel welded storage tank[J].Oil & Gas Storage and Transportation,2015,34(01):882.[doi:10.6047/j.issn.1000-8241.2015.08.017]
[2]张志强 彭常飞 赵振兴 付丽 赵树炳.储罐锚栓座结构设计方法[J].油气储运,2016,35(预出版):1.
ZHANG Zhiqiang,PENG Changfei,ZHAO Zhenxing,et al.Structural design of anchor bolt chairs of storage tanks[J].Oil & Gas Storage and Transportation,2016,35(01):1.
[3]张志强,彭常飞,赵振兴,等.储罐锚栓座结构设计方法[J].油气储运,2015,34(10):1138.[doi:10.6047/j.issn.1000-8241.2015.10.025]
ZHANG Zhiqiang,PENG Changfei,ZHAO Zhenxing,et al.Structural design of anchor bolt chairs of storage tanks[J].Oil & Gas Storage and Transportation,2015,34(01):1138.[doi:10.6047/j.issn.1000-8241.2015.10.025]
[4]马伟平 蔡亮 王禹钦 潘腾.国内外储罐泄漏检测技术现状[J].油气储运,2016,35(预出版):1.
MA Weiping,CAI Liang,WANG Yuqin,et al. A review on status of domestic and foreign tank leakage detection technologies[J].Oil & Gas Storage and Transportation,2016,35(01):1.
[5]王朝璋,慕进良,钟卡.国内外储罐泄漏检测技术现状[J].油气储运,2016,35(10):1038.[doi:10.6047/j.issn.1000-8241.2016.10.002]
WANG Chaozhang,MU Jinliang,ZHONG Ka.A review on status of domestic and foreign tank leakage detection technologies[J].Oil & Gas Storage and Transportation,2016,35(01):1038.[doi:10.6047/j.issn.1000-8241.2016.10.002]
[6]王书良.储罐温度分布对计量精度的影响[J].油气储运,2017,36(预出版):1.
WANG Shuliang.Influence of tank temperature distribution on metering accuracy[J].Oil & Gas Storage and Transportation,2017,36(01):1.
[7]李薇 牛军强 马云 闫建宇 胡炎兴 聂永臣.国内外地上钢质储罐底板外阴极保护标准对比[J].油气储运,2018,37(预出版):1.
LI Wei,NIU Junqiang,MA Yun,et al.Comparison between domestic and foreign cathodic protection standards for the bottom plates of aboveground steel tanks[J].Oil & Gas Storage and Transportation,2018,37(01):1.
[8]刘小川 刘硕 顾成曦 许晶禹.小型航煤储罐的吸瘪机理[J].油气储运,2021,40(01):1.
LIU Xiaochuan,LIU Shuo,GU Chengxi,et al.Collapse mechanism of small aviation kerosene tank[J].Oil & Gas Storage and Transportation,2021,40(01):1.
作者简介:刘小川,男,1973 年生,高级工程师,1998 年毕业 于中国人民解放军后勤工程学院油料储运专业,现从事油气储 运方向的研究工作。地址:北京市海淀区马甸路2 号,100088。 电话:010-59890340。Email:liuxc@cnaf.com
通信作者:许晶禹,男,1975 年生,研究员,2007 年博士毕业于中 国科学院力学研究所工程力学专业,现从事多相流体力学、油气储 运理论与技术方面研究工作。地址:北京市海淀区北四环西路15 号,100190。电话:010-82544179。Email:xujingyu@imech.ac.cn